The PA Paradox: High Investment, Low Trust
A consistent challenge in HR? Proving People Analytics ROI and it delivers real value. Business leaders often dismiss PA as “HR fluff” because it rarely ties to outcomes like revenue, productivity, or cost savings. In fact, while 75% of organizations have invested in People Analytics, only 10% claim to achieve the highest level of impact (McKinsey, 2023).
But economic downturns change the game.
When company survival hinges on cost-cutting without losing talent or productivity, People Analytics becomes indispensable.
Layoffs—often seen as the default fix—can backfire spectacularly:
- Rehiring Costs: Companies spend 1.5x the saved payroll rehiring post-recession.
- Productivity Loss: Remaining employees face 20% heavier workloads, spiking burnout risk (Gallup).
- Long-Term Damage: companies that cut staff later rehire the same roles at higher costs.
Meanwhile, 67% of CEOs cite economic uncertainty as their #1 threat (PwC), yet default to short term solution – layoffs. This is where People Analytics shifts HR from cost center to strategic business partner, solving three survival priorities:
- Immediate Cost Savings: Cut labor, hiring, and overhead costs without 100% relying on layoffs.
- Productivity Protection: Optimize workloads to prevent burnout and output drops.
- Agility for Recovery: Reskill employees and forecast talent needs for post-crisis growth.
The bottom line: In downturns, skepticism about PA melts away when it solves CFO-level problems. Here’s how.
9 Strategies to Prove PA ROI (with suggestions to leveraging AI Tools)
1. Retrain Employees, Don’t Replace Them
Business Priority: Fill critical roles (e.g., AI, cybersecurity) with minimum cost or recruitment fees.
PA Solution:
- Skills Gap Analysis: Map existing employee skills against future business needs.
-
Reskilling Paths: Identify “skills adjacencies” (e.g., a marketer with data skills → data analytics roles).
-
How It Works:
-
Audit HRIS/LMS data for certifications, projects, and training history.
-
Deploy AI tools like Eightfold or Gloat to match employees to high-demand roles.
-
Partner with L&D to build personalized upskilling plans.
-
PA ROI Business Case: Cisco reskilled 500 engineers for cloud roles, cutting hiring costs by $18M (Cisco Annual Report).
PA ROI Metric: % of critical roles filled internally.
2. Optimize Workloads, Not Headcount
Business Priority: Maximize productivity without adding headcount.
PA Solution:
-
Productivity Analytics: Analyze task completion rates, collaboration patterns, and time-tracking data.
-
How It Works:
-
Use tools like ActivTrak or Microsoft Viva to measure team output.
-
Identify underutilized employees or teams with excess capacity.
-
Redistribute tasks (e.g., shift customer service overflow to quieter teams).
-
PA ROI Metric: Tasks completed per employee per week.
3. Slash Overtime with Predictive Scheduling
Business Priority: Reduce labor costs without burnout.
PA Solution:
-
Demand Forecasting: Use historical sales, seasonal trends, and attrition data to predict staffing needs.
-
How It Works:
-
Integrate ERP data (e.g., sales forecasts) with workforce schedules.
-
Deploy AI tools like UKG Dimensions to automate shift planning.
-
Flag departments prone to overtime spikes for real-time adjustments.
-
PA ROI Business Case: FedEx cut overtime by 22% using AI-driven workforce planning (Forbes).
4. Target Costly Attrition Risks
Business Priority: Retain revenue-critical talent (e.g., top salespeople, engineers).
PA Solution:
-
Flight Risk Modeling: Analyze engagement surveys, promotion history, and job market trends.
-
How It Works:
-
Use tools like Visier or Workday to score attrition risk.
-
Prioritize retention efforts for high-risk, high-impact employees.
-
Offer personalized incentives (e.g., project ownership, flexible hours).
-
PA ROI Business Case: Microsoft reduced attrition in top-performing sales teams by through their AI attrition model (Microsoft Work Trend Index).
PA ROI Metric: Cost of attrition per high performer.
5. Link Roles to Revenue Outcomes
Business Priority: Protect roles that directly drive profit.
PA Solution:
-
Workforce Modeling: Map how departments impact KPIs (e.g., sales, customer retention).
-
How It Works:
-
Correlate headcount data with revenue/operational metrics.
-
Use Power BI dashboards to show HR’s impact on business outcomes e.g. training / reskilling critical roles; retention of top sales; hiring costs of sales roles; time for new hire to generate revenue etc
-
Example: Prove HR business partners drive 12% higher sales productivity.
-
PA ROI Metric: Revenue per employee by department.
6. Rightsize Real Estate with Remote Work Data
Business Priority: Cut office costs without productivity loss.
PA Solution:
-
Productivity-by-Location Analytics: Compare output for remote vs. in-office teams.
-
How It Works:
-
Track collaboration (Slack/Teams activity), task completion, and engagement by location.
-
Use tools like OfficeSpace Software to optimize office layouts, or Microsoft Viva Insights for hybrid work analytics.
-
Example: Downsize office space by 40% if remote teams perform equally.
-
PA ROI Business Case: Dropbox saved $50M/year by downsizing offices (Dropbox ESG Report).
7. Replace Guesswork with Hiring Forecasts
Business Priority: Avoid over-hiring and sudden freezes.
PA Solution:
-
Predictive Talent Demand Planning: Model future needs using attrition rates, growth projections, and market trends.
-
How It Works:
-
Integrate financial forecasts (e.g., revenue targets) with workforce data.
-
Use Workday Prism Analytics to simulate hiring scenarios.
-
Example: Pause hiring for roles with 6-month+ lead time to proficiency.
-
PA ROI Metric: Accuracy of hiring forecasts vs. actual needs.
8. Turn Employee Data into Cost-Savings Levers
Business Priority: Find non-obvious savings in workflows.
PA Solution:
-
Labor Cost Analytics: Identify inefficiencies in scheduling, overtime, and task allocation.
-
How It Works:
-
Audit payroll data for patterns (e.g., departments with consistent overtime) or utilise Labor cost analytics platforms like ADP DataCloud.
-
Use Tableau dashboards to visualize cost drivers.
-
Example: Fix scheduling gaps causing 15% overtime in logistics teams.
-
PA ROI Business Case: A logistics firm saved $8M/year by optimizing schedules
PA ROI Metric: Workforce productivity vs cost.
9. Prove HR’s Impact with CFO-Friendly Metrics
Business Priority: Trust but verify HR’s value.
PA Solution:
-
HR-to-Finance Translation: Convert HR initiatives into business outcomes.
-
How It Works:
-
Reskilling → Reduced hiring costs ($30K saved per internal hire).
-
Retention → Protected revenue (e.g., retaining a top salesperson = $500K/year).
-
Flexible work → Lower overhead (e.g., 30% office cost reduction).
-
PA ROI Business Case: Salesforce linked PA-driven retention programs to millions in savings (Salesforce Annual Report).
PA ROI Metric: HR cost savings as % of total budget.
PA Is the Bridge Between HR and Business
In downturns, CFOs don’t need HR to “do more with less”—they need HR to solve business problems with data. People Analytics repositions HR as a strategic ally by:
-
Cutting Costs → Reducing hiring, overtime, and real estate spend.
-
Protecting Productivity → Optimizing workloads and retaining critical talent.
-
Enabling Agility → Forecasting needs and reskilling at scale.
