“Of course we’re data-driven. We have reports and dashboards.”
If I had a dollar every time I heard that, I’d have retired already.
The truth? Most companies say they’re data-driven. Most people managers say they use data to guide decisions. But peel back the surface, and you’ll see a very different story:
- Managers ignoring insights in favour of gut feel
- Dashboards collecting dust
- Data teams scrambling to prove “usefulness” with no real follow-through
So let’s talk about it:
👉 What does a truly data-driven organization look like?
👉 Why is there such a gap between claim and reality?
👉 And what can HR and business leaders actually do to change it?
🧠 Being Data-Driven Is Not About Dashboards
Let’s be clear. Data-driven is not a tech label. It’s a mindset.
A company can spend millions on a shiny BI tool and still make decisions in meeting rooms based on hierarchy and hunches. A manager can quote Net Promoter Scores and still promote someone because “they’re a good culture fit.”
What makes an organization truly data-driven?
- Leaders who ask for evidence before making decisions
- Managers who understand and question the data—not ignore it
- Teams who trust and act on insights, not just admire them
Being data-driven doesn’t mean replacing intuition. It means grounding intuition in evidence.
🚧 The Real Barriers
So why aren’t we there yet? Here’s what the research (and experience) says:
1. Culture eats dashboards for breakfast
Many companies don’t have a culture that rewards data-informed decisions. They reward seniority, confidence, consensus, or speed. Data becomes a “nice to have” — not a decision requirement.
📊 A 2024 Wavestone study found 60% companies struggle to build a data-driven culture despite leadership support for analytics
2. Low data fluency at the front line
Managers are expected to interpret retention trends, engagement scores, or DEI metrics — but no one trained them how. HR sends the report. Managers nod. Then default back to gut feel.
3. No consequences for ignoring the data
If a hiring manager bypasses recruitment data, or a business leader ignores performance signals — nothing happens. Being data-driven is optional, not embedded.
4. Dashboards ≠ decisions
A dashboard is a tool. A decision is a behavior. If we build insights that don’t link to business outcomes, no one uses them.
🏆 Case Study: So What Does It Look Like When It Works?
Let’s look at a few companies who’ve built real data-driven practices into their culture:
📌 Microsoft: Leadership Emphasis on Data Culture
Chris Capossela, Ex Microsoft’s CMO, has highlighted that Microsoft shifted toward a culture where data must underpin every major decision—“if the data is not there, you just move on,” he said in interviews
📌 Airbnb: Embedded Data Partners and Scientists in HR
Airbnb embedded data scientists directly into functional teams, including HR. The goal: co-create analytics that answered real business problems, not just churn out reports. The people analytics team partnered closely with leaders to improve hiring processes, diversity initiatives, and performance reviews.
📌 ING: Linking People Metrics to Business Levers
ING used people analytics to connect engagement with branch performance and customer satisfaction scores. They treat engagement as a revenue-related metric, not just an HR vanity stat. (@Visier)
📌 Unilever: AI-Powered Recruiting
Unilever uses AI to process over 1 million applications and speed hiring times through using machine learning-based candidate screening. (@Bernard Marr)
📈 Best Practices to Build a Data-Driven Workforce
Here’s what I’ve seen work — and what the research backs up.
✅ 1. Normalize the question: “What does the data say?”
Leaders must model this. In every business review, every talent conversation, ask:
- “What data supports this?”
- “How confident are we in the trend?”
- “What’s missing?”
Make it uncomfortable to decide without data.
✅ 2. Invest in data literacy — especially in HR and people managers
Not everyone needs to be a data scientist. But if your HRBPs and team leads can’t interpret a turnover heatmap or a trend line — your data will never reach its potential.
✅ 3. Link metrics to business value
Don’t track for the sake of tracking. Tie analytics to revenue, cost, risk, or growth. Show how retention affects hiring cost. How engagement links to sales. Make the data speak the business language.
✅ 4. Co-create with users, don’t dictate
If people managers don’t see themselves in the metric design, they won’t use the metric. Build analytics with them, not for them.
✅ 5. Celebrate data wins
When a team uses data to make a better decision — highlight it. Share stories. Create internal case studies. This shifts data from a report to a capability.
💡 Final Thought: You Don’t Need 100 Metrics — You Need 5 Good Ones People Trust
Being data-driven doesn’t mean measuring everything.
It means acting on the right things.
So the next time someone says “We’re data-driven,” ask them:
What decisions have you made differently because of the data?
If the answer is silence, you’ve got work to do.
But the upside? You now know where to start.
📩 Want to stay ahead of the curve?
If you found this useful, subscribe to my People Analytics Insider newsletter for:
- Exclusive case studies (like the bias audit we did for a Fortune 500 company)
- Templates (data governance checklist, HR metrics guide)
- Deep dives on turning analytics into action
🚀 Ready to upgrade your people analytics in your firm? Let’s check out the HR metrics you should be tracking
